03 / Check the evidence
What’s established vs experimental
A big claim deserves a closer look. These words can help you tell different kinds of information apart.

Category 01
Established care for a specific condition
These are treatments used in medical practice for particular problems, supported by evidence and clinical experience. “Established” does not mean right for everyone, risk-free, or guaranteed to work. For example, a temporary drain for certain fluid problems is a specific procedure—not a replacement brain.
Category 02
Experimental approaches
Researchers study new approaches to learn whether they are safe and useful. Research involving people should have appropriate independent oversight. Experimental does not mean proven, available to everyone, or likely to help a particular person. Read about research for patients and families at Great Ormond Street Hospital.
Category 03
Unsupported or unverified claims
These are claims that have not been backed up by enough reliable evidence, or that cannot yet be checked. A confident headline or a person’s description alone is not proof that a treatment exists or works.
A clear distinction
Whole-brain transplants are not established treatment.
Whole-brain transplantation is not an established medical treatment. Do not confuse it with established brain operations or research involving cells or tissue. A claim about an organization’s work is not evidence of medical capability.
Pause and check a claim
- Who published it, and are they qualified to explain it?
- What evidence supports the claim?
- Do independent experts agree?
- Does it explain risks and uncertainty?
- Is someone promising a cure or a guaranteed result?
Bring anything confusing to your own clinical team. It’s okay to ask them to help you check it.
More detail: what does evidence tell us?
Evidence can be stronger or weaker, and findings from one group or condition may not apply to another. A study is a way to learn, not proof that a treatment is available or suitable for children.
Sources and review
These sources illustrate a specific established procedure and research context; they do not establish the transplant claim. Independent source verification and qualified clinical review of the transplant clarification are still required before publication. Access dates need to be recorded.
- External ventricular drainage — Great Ormond Street Hospital; update date not identified.
- Research and innovation for patients and families — Great Ormond Street Hospital; update date not identified.